ORDER ARTICLE PERMISSIONS/REPRINTS/OFFPRINTS/TEACHING NOTES
To order permissions to include this article in textbooks, edited volumes, course booklets, online/digital course packs, etc., and/or to order multiple individual hard copies for classroom use, please contact the copyright owners, NeilsonJournals' Publishing Editor, Peter Neilson at pneilson@neilsonjournals.com
Ethical Leadership and Board Decision Making: The Case of Kohl's CEO Misconduct
Samira Fallah
University of Mary Washington, USA
Mehdi Samimi
The City College of New York, USA
Volume 19: 2026, pp. 00-00; ABSTRACT
This case examines the ethical and governance challenges faced by the board of Kohl’s
in April 2025 after an investigation revealed that newly appointed CEO, Ashley Buchanan, failed to
disclose a conflict of interest involving vendor-related decisions. The board discovered that
Buchanan had a romantic relationship with Chandra Holt, founder of Incredibrew, whose products
Kohl’s agreed to carry under favorable terms specified by Buchanan. Holt was also affiliated with
Boston Consulting Group, which Kohl’s hired under a multimillion-dollar consulting agreement
supported by Buchanan. This finding places the board in a difficult position: terminating Buchanan
shortly after his appointment could damage the board’s reputation, raise concerns about its
competence in leadership succession and create organizational instability, while failing to act
decisively could be viewed as neglecting its fiduciary responsibilities and undermine stakeholders
trust. The case provides an opportunity for students to apply principles of agency theory and
examine the role of the board of directors in addressing executive conflicts of interest and the
tensions among ethical, strategic, and reputational considerations in organizational decision
making.
Keywords: board oversight, agency theory, corporate governance, ethical leadership, executive
misconduct, conflict of interest, CEO succession.